Kickstarter ·

What Happens If Your Kickstarter Doesn't Fund? The Honest Answer

Short answer: If your Kickstarter doesn't fund, no money moves. Backers aren't charged, you receive nothing and owe nothing, and you can relaunch. The real cost is the ad spend, the months and a cold list.

What Happens If Your Kickstarter Doesn't Fund? The Honest Answer
Photo by Yan Krukau on Pexels

Nothing happens to the money. That’s the honest mechanical answer, and it’s usually the part people are most frightened of before they look it up.

Your clock runs out, the page switches to “funding unsuccessful”, and the pledges evaporate. No cards are charged, nothing lands in your account, and you don’t owe a backer or the platform a penny.

So that’s what happens if your Kickstarter doesn’t fund, in the narrow sense. The wider answer is more uncomfortable, because the money was never the thing you actually spent. I’m an official Kickstarter Expert Partner, and this is the conversation I’d rather have with a founder twelve weeks before launch than the week after.

What happens if your Kickstarter doesn’t fund: the mechanics

Kickstarter is all-or-nothing by design. Backers enter payment details when they pledge, but a pledge is an authorisation rather than a payment. Nothing is collected until the campaign closes above its goal.

Kickstarter’s own help pages say it about as bluntly as it can be said: if a campaign ends without reaching its funding goal, no money changes hands.

That has a few consequences worth spelling out, because founders worry about all of them.

  • No fees. The 5% platform cut and the payment processing fees only apply to funded projects. An unsuccessful campaign costs nothing on the platform.
  • No refunds to process. There’s nothing to refund. The authorisations simply expire.
  • No obligation to anyone. You promised rewards in exchange for money you never received. The contract never came into being.
  • The page stays up, quietly. Kickstarter has no browse area for unfunded projects and removes them from Google and Bing. It’s still findable through Kickstarter’s internal search and on your creator profile, but the wider internet won’t stumble on it.
  • You can go again. Kickstarter says you are welcome to relaunch, and there is no waiting period to serve. A new project needs a different title and gets a new URL, and pledges don’t transfer.

Read that list back and it’s genuinely less frightening than the thing people imagine, which is usually some version of being personally on the hook. You aren’t. Kickstarter built all-or-nothing partly to protect creators from exactly that.

The rule really is absolute, though, and the clearest illustration is a game called Alpha Colony, from a studio called DreamQuest Games. It asked for $50,000 and finished on $49,972. Twenty-eight dollars short, and it received nothing. Kotaku asked Kickstarter whether they would bend the rule for a gap that small and they would not, which is the correct answer however much it stings: a threshold that moves for near-misses is not a threshold.

The detail most people skip past is that it was the second attempt. The first had asked for $500,000 and raised $101,472. Both campaigns failed, but only one of them failed because of twenty-eight dollars. The other failed for the reason almost every campaign fails, which is the next section.

The bill that does arrive

Here’s the bit nobody says out loud. The pledges cost you nothing, and everything you spent getting to them is gone.

Ad spend is the big one. If you ran pre-launch ads to build a list, that budget was spent to generate signups and the signups didn’t convert. Nobody is giving it back.

Then the production of the campaign itself. Video, photography, a few rounds of edits. Samples from the factory, often several. Tooling deposits if you got far enough to commit, which is the one that actually hurts.

And the months. Three to six of them for most products, longer for hardware, during which you weren’t doing anything else.

The quietest loss is the list. A few thousand email addresses from people who signed up excited, watched a campaign not fund, and now sit in your inbox going cold. Lists decay fast. The group that would have pledged in week one is noticeably less interested eight weeks later, and a relaunch six months out is working with an audience that has largely forgotten you.

None of that is a reason to feel stupid. It’s a reason to understand what happened before you spend the next lot.

Why it happened, almost every time

There are plenty of causes and I’ve gone through the full set in why Kickstarter campaigns fail. But if you want the one that explains most unfunded campaigns, it’s this.

The goal was set from production costs instead of from what the audience could actually clear.

It happens for understandable reasons. You do the sums with the factory, the minimum order is 1,000 units, the tooling is a fixed lump, and the number that comes out the other end is £60,000. So £60,000 goes in the box. Nobody at any point asked whether the 900 people on the pre-launch list could produce £60,000 in a weekend.

That’s the wrong direction of travel. The goal should be sized to what your list can clear in the first 24 to 48 hours, and the production economics should be solved somewhere else: a smaller first run, stretch goals, a second campaign, your own money. I’ve made the full argument in how to set a Kickstarter funding goal, including what to do when the minimum order quantity genuinely won’t bend.

If you want to see the arithmetic on your own numbers, the day one calculator takes your list size, your average pledge and a realistic conversion rate and tells you what day one would actually produce. It takes about ninety seconds and it’s the single most useful thing you can do before committing to a figure.

Not sure whether your problem is the goal, the list or the product itself? A £60 strategy call is the cheapest way to find out before you spend another few thousand finding out the expensive way.

The reason this matters so much is that day one sets the shape of everything after it. My position is that day one should hit 100% of your goal, not a third of it. Thirty percent on day one is roughly the average, and the average campaign has a badly set goal, so copying the average is copying the mistake. I’ve laid out the reasoning in the Kickstarter day one benchmark.

A campaign that funds in 48 hours never has to ask what happens if it doesn’t fund.

Deciding what to do next

Deciding whether to relaunch

You can relaunch tomorrow. That doesn’t mean you should.

The relaunch only works if something material has changed, and the mechanics are their own subject, which I’ve covered in relaunching a Kickstarter campaign. What I’d want to see before anyone goes again:

  • A goal sized to the list, not to the factory invoice.
  • A bigger, warmer list. Not 500 more signups. A list that’s been emailed properly and segmented into people who’ve said they’ll pledge in hour one. How big it needs to be depends on your price point.
  • Evidence people will pay, not evidence they’ll click. Signups prove interest at a price of zero.
  • A page that converts the traffic you already had. If people arrived last time and didn’t pledge, more traffic is just a more expensive version of the same result.
  • A sequence you can actually run. The order of work matters, and it’s set out in how to promote a Kickstarter.

Change one of those and you’ve tinkered. Change three and you’ve got a different campaign.

When relaunching is the wrong answer

Sometimes the campaign wasn’t the problem. Be honest about which of these you’re looking at.

If decent, warm traffic arrived and almost nobody pledged, the product or the price is being rejected, not the marketing. Relaunching the same offer to the same people is paying twice for the same information.

If you never managed to build a list at all despite spending real money trying, your cost of acquiring a customer may simply be higher than your margin. That’s a business problem and crowdfunding won’t fix it.

And if the honest answer is that you were only excited about it in the first month, don’t spend another six out of stubbornness. A campaign not funding is a cheap “no” compared with most ways of learning the same thing.

Starting the next one

Launching so the question never comes up

The whole of this post is avoidable, and it’s avoidable in the run-up rather than during the campaign.

Build the list first. Size the goal to what that list can clear in 48 hours. Launch to people who already know what’s coming, and let Kickstarter’s own traffic compound on top of a page that’s already funded.

On length, Kickstarter’s own guidance recommends 30 days or less on the basis that shorter campaigns create urgency. I run 37 to 45 days instead, and my last campaign ran 45, because the free platform coverage and editorial attention only accrue while you’re live and I’d rather have the extra fortnight of it. That’s a preference, not a correction of theirs, and either way the decisive 48 hours sit at the front.

Funding isn’t something you push a campaign towards over six weeks. It’s something you arrive with.

Key takeaways

  • An unfunded Kickstarter charges no backer, pays no creator and costs nothing in platform fees.
  • Kickstarter’s help pages state that no money changes hands when a goal isn’t reached.
  • Unfunded pages are hidden from browse and de-indexed from Google, but stay on your creator profile.
  • Goal and deadline are locked at launch; the only fix is a new project.
  • Most unfunded campaigns set the goal from production costs rather than from pre-launch list size.
  • You can relaunch immediately, but only a materially different campaign is worth relaunching.

Want a hand with yours?

If you’re reading this the week after a campaign ended, the useful next step isn’t a relaunch date. It’s working out which of the five things above actually went wrong, because the answer changes what you do next entirely.

My free ebook covers the pre-launch work that decides this, and if you’d rather just talk it through, a £60 strategy call will tell you whether you’ve got a goal problem, a list problem or a product problem. Cheaper than finding out twice.

Frequently asked questions

Do backers get charged if a Kickstarter doesn't reach its goal? +

No. Kickstarter's help pages put it plainly: if a campaign ends without reaching its funding goal, no money changes hands. Pledges are authorisations, not payments, so nothing is taken from anyone's card and no refunds are needed. Kickstarter's 5% fee and the payment processing fees only apply to successfully funded projects, so the platform costs you nothing either.

Do I have to cancel my old project before I relaunch it? +

Not if it has already ended. An unsuccessful campaign is finished, and you can simply start a fresh draft and copy content or import rewards across from it. Cancelling is only for projects that are still live and that you want to pull early. Kickstarter does require the new project to have a different title and it gets a new URL, so pledges and follower counts don't carry over.

Can Kickstarter restrict my account if a project doesn't fund? +

No. An unsuccessful campaign is a normal outcome on an all-or-nothing platform, not a breach of anything, and Kickstarter's own stats page shows well over half of launched projects end that way. Your account stays in good standing and you're free to launch again. The only thing that genuinely damages your standing is funding a project and then going quiet on your backers.

Can I extend my Kickstarter deadline if I'm running out of time? +

No. The funding goal and the deadline are both locked the moment you launch, and Kickstarter says it cannot extend the deadline on a campaign that has ended. The only route to a different goal or a different length is to cancel while live, or let it finish and build a new project. Which is exactly why the goal is worth getting right before you press the button.

What should I do if my Kickstarter is nearly funded with days to go? +

Spend on the gap. A page sitting at 85% funded converts far better than one at 11%, because a backer can see it is going to make it, so this is the point in a campaign where paid traffic and a direct ask to your list work hardest. Email everyone who has already pledged and ask them to share it, and work out your return target before you raise the budget.

Will a failed Kickstarter show up on Google or on my profile? +

Barely. Kickstarter has no browse section for projects that missed their goal and removes those pages from external search engines, so they shouldn't appear in Google or Bing results. They stay reachable through Kickstarter's own search and on your creator profile, where past campaigns are listed whether they funded or not. Almost nobody outside the platform will ever see it.

Ready to launch yours?

Start small with a £60 strategy call — or go straight to the full Done-for-You and I'll build it for you.

Not ready for either? Tell me what you're stuck on and I'll reply by email.